Chair Dalton Exits Historical Commission After 25 Years Amid Leadership Vacuum

Key Points

  • Chair Craig Dalton and Member James McKenna announced resignations effective July 2026
  • Demolition of the 1780 Augustus Simmons House paused pending a board site visit
  • Eagle Scout project for Old Town Burial Grounds cleanup set for June start
  • Commission to spend remaining FY2026 funds on stone cleaning and trial stump removal
  • Finalization of Bradford House preservation restriction and plowing access remains a priority

The Kingston Historical Commission faces a significant leadership transition following the announcement that Chair Craig Dalton will step down this July, ending a quarter-century of service to the town’s preservation efforts. Dalton’s departure, coupled with the resignation of member James McKenna, leaves the board searching for new volunteers to manage the town’s heritage as Kingston approaches its 300th anniversary. Dalton told the commission, I'm going to retire this year. It's been 25 years... we're going to need a new Chair. McKenna, who will also wrap up his tenure in July, noted the administrative burden of the role, stating, I had to choose between this and the Watershed Association. Keeping up with this stuff is more work than I thought it would be, especially posting the minutes.

The leadership crisis comes at a critical moment for the town’s historic inventory. The commission recently delayed a decision on a demolition permit for the Augustus Simmons House at 5 Reed Street. The 1780 Cape-style home was recently damaged by fire, and while the permit suggests the kitchen might remain, Dalton expressed hope that the structural integrity of the nearly 250-year-old building could be salvaged. I don't know if this thing can be saved, gutted, and rebuilt to save the exterior and the beams, Dalton noted, suggesting that the owners are open to further inspection. Member J. McKenna agreed that a closer look was necessary: I think it might behoove us to do that, to get together and do a field trip and go out and see if it's worth looking into. The board will coordinate a site visit before acting on the permit.

In contrast, the commission moved quickly to clear a property at 9 Pebbles Lane for redevelopment. Despite the home’s age, Dalton observed that it had been modified so extensively that it no longer met the criteria for historical significance, noting the trend of neighbors tearing down the old and doubling the size of everything in the waterfront area. J. McKenna added that while he had personal concerns about overbuilding the lot, the structure lacked architectural merit. Motion Made by J. McKenna to determine that 9 Pebbles Lane is not a historically significant structure and authorize the demolition. Motion Passed (4-0-0).

Preparation for Kingston’s 300th anniversary took center stage as Eagle Scout candidate Declan Mangan presented a proposal to revitalize the Old Town Burial Grounds. Mangan plans to lead his troop in a debris cleanup and landscape the area surrounding a new Revolutionary War monument. We're going to organize the troop to pick up all of the debris and sticks that are currently scattered around the cemetery, Mangan said, detailing plans for a reflection bench and a perennial garden. Member Lynne Carreiro suggested reaching out to the community for support, noting, The Kingston Garden Club might be willing to donate a couple of the plants to put into the landscaping.

Funding for the project, estimated at over $600, will be raised privately. Mangan’s mentor, Dean, told the board, It's our responsibility, so we will self-fund and do fundraising with friends and family or figure something else out. The commission requested a formal sketch of the landscaping before the planned June 6 start date, aiming to have the site ready for the town’s Proclamation Day celebration on June 27. The project aligns with the commission’s broader push to utilize remaining Fiscal Year 2026 funds for cemetery maintenance, including a $160 trial run for chemical stump removal and the purchase of specialized cleaning supplies for headstones.

The commission also addressed ongoing maintenance frustrations at the Bradford House. Member Kenneth Brack raised alarms regarding a lack of winter access, reporting a dispute with the Highway Superintendent over snow plowing on the driveway, which some officials claim is a private road while others identify it as the historic Landing Road right-of-way. No fire equipment could have gotten near the Bradford House in February, Brack warned, urging the board to bring the matter before the Selectmen. Additionally, the commission is moving to finalize a long-delayed preservation restriction on the property to ensure its protection regardless of the future of the historical society.

As the meeting progressed, the commission’s work was briefly interrupted by members of the Democratic Town Committee, highlighting a room-scheduling conflict at Town Hall. Members Linda Ragosta and Thomas Vendetti arrived as the board hurried to conclude its business. While Ragosta expressed a willingness to step into more active duties, she admitted to having no idea what it entails to chair the group. Dalton encouraged her, saying the role simply requires an inquisitive, organized mind. The commission plans to campaign for new members among Main Street residents to fill the impending vacancies before the July transition.

In other business, the commission responded to a research request from Elm Street resident Craig Swinmer regarding a historic cattle path between his property and 485 Elm Street. Dalton shared a personal connection, noting his wife’s grandfather used to drive dairy herds through the area in the early 1900s. K. Brack suggested the resident consult with the town archivist, noting that a lot of the maps are online now.